Band members include Captain Beans, Captain Captain Mikee, Captain Crystal Shrimp, Captain Dad, Captain Edward Undercurrent, Captain Figgy, Captain Long Goose, Captain Mustard, Captain Scerwy, Captain Scurvy Jamz the Navigator, Captain Skinteeth, Captain Spellcheck, Captain Sorry, Captain Mabel Canagement, and Johnny.

Former band members include Captain Krillian Monohawk, Captain The Tugboat, and Captain Violent.